Question · Is astrological compatibility reliable?Reading3 min
The Lafter magazineMarrakech,
Question · astrology

Is astrological compatibility reliable?

Astrological compatibility: what 10 million married couples show, Jung's experiment, and a test for two that measures what really matters.

Jay, founder of LafterBy Jay, founder of LafterPublished on 3 min read
FREN
The short answerin 30 seconds

No, astrological compatibility doesn't predict whether a couple will work: across 10 million married couples in England and Wales, no combination of signs stands out from chance. What research does find is the importance of how you repair after a disagreement. “What's your sign?” remains, on the other hand, an excellent question to start talking about yourself.

Answer checked on 22 November 20263 sources

Is astrological compatibility reliable: the answer in detail

The largest test is David Voas's, at the University of Manchester, in 2007: he crossed the sun signs of 10 million married couples from the census of England and Wales. If fire and water avoided each other, it would show on such a number. None of the 144 combinations stands out. The only anomaly, an excess of couples born on the same day, is explained by data entry errors.

Astrologers object that a real test compares whole charts, not signs. That's fair, and it's what Carl Gustav Jung did with 483 married couples in the early 1950s: after a spectacular first batch, the next ones fell back to average, and Jung concluded that the result reflected the researchers' state of mind, not the planets. The full story is in guide No. 04.

Research on couples, for its part, has never found a “compatible” profile. It found ways of handling differences: in John Gottman's work, everything plays out in the repair after a disagreement, not in the absence of disagreement. Even the algorithms of apps for singles haven't shown they can predict whether two people will get on (Finkel et al., 2012).

Signs still have real value, though: that of a shared language. At a table in the Medina or a café in Guéliz, “you're very Moon in Cancer” opens a conversation about emotions in five seconds. Use it to ask the next question, not to classify someone. It's the same lesson as for mirror hours and the Barnum effect: what you read there mostly speaks about you.

In practice

What to do, in 3 steps

  1. Each answer in secretQuestions about your couple, for example “Who sends the first message after an argument?”, with three possible answers: me, rather the other, we both handle it badly.
  2. Compare your answersThe score doesn't matter. The disagreements do: that's where the conversation starts.
  3. Take one disagreement at a timeOne line per conversation, not all of them on the same evening. The full test, to do as a couple, is in guide No. 04.
What people ask us

Frequently asked questions

Are fire and water signs incompatible?

No data shows it: across 10 million married couples, no combination of signs deviates from chance. The risk comes rather from both believing it: every argument then looks like fate.

Is synastry more reliable than sign compatibility?

It compares whole charts, which is finer. But Jung's experiment on 483 couples found nothing stable, and he concluded there was no causality.

What should you ask instead of their sign?

“How do you show someone you care about them?” That question says more about a relationship than any birth chart.

Sources and method

What this text is based on

  1. David Voas, “Ten million marriages: an astrological detective story”, Skeptical Inquirer, 2008; University of Manchester, 2007. Open the source
  2. Smithsonian Magazine, “Good news: astrology doesn't impact the success of your marriage” (University of Manchester study). Open the source
  3. Finkel, Eastwick, Karney, Reis and Sprecher, “Online Dating: A Critical Analysis From the Perspective of Psychological Science”, Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 2012. Open the source

Spotted an error, or a source to add? Write to contact@lafter.ma: every correction is dated.

The long version

Article11:11, 22:22: what mirror hours really meanSeeing 11:11 everywhere? What angel numerology says, what psychology really observes, and what to do with these moments, especially after a break-up.Read →

Words in this answer

Places mentioned

  • Marrakech
  • Morocco
  • Medina
  • Guéliz

How to cite this text

Prost, Jérémy (Jay). “Is astrological compatibility reliable?”. Lafter questions, Lafter, Marrakech, updated 22 November 2026. lafter.ma/en/questions/is-astrological-compatibility-reliable

Jay, founder of Lafter and author of the guides
The authorJay · Jérémy Prost, founder of Lafter

I founded Lafter in Marrakech, a circle where you see the same faces every week. I write these texts like a reporter: a question that concerns me, the studies that answer it, and my own story when it helps. Every figure is sourced.

My story and the method →
The fixed date

Wherever you live in Marrakech, Tuesday 8pm.

The Lafter Coffee: a table composed by affinity, in a partner café. Free to discover, no commitment.

Save my seat