How do you read the sky?
Tick the sentences that most often sound like you. Answer for the bad-day version of you, not the Sunday-morning one.
It's this request, not the planets, that decides what astrology will do to you. The result isn't a label: it changes with the periods of your life, and above all with break-ups.
Four thousand years of looking up.
One April evening, about 2,435 years ago, a scribe in Babylon engraved on a clay tablet the position of the Moon, Jupiter and Venus at the birth of a child. Then he added: “things will go well for you”. It is the oldest known horoscope. We have only about thirty of them. And since then, we've never stopped doing the same thing: looking at the sky to find out whether someone will love us.
I did it too, on a rooftop in Marrakech, facing the Koutoubia, phone in hand. I won't lie to you: I read my horoscope, I know my ascendant, and in 2024, after a break-up I told in the previous guide, I spent months seeing signs everywhere. So the question of this guide isn't “should you believe in it?”. It's: what exactly am I asking of the sky, and what can it really give me back?
To answer, it takes three investigations: history, science, and me. I'll start with history, because it already explains half the misunderstanding.
Nine dates to understand where what you read in the morning comes from.
- ~ 410 BC
Babylon. The first horoscope.
Mesopotamian priests had been watching the sky for the king for centuries: eclipses, omens, harvests. Then the idea tipped over: what if the sky also spoke about an individual? About thirty birth horoscopes on tablets have come down to us (Rochberg, Babylonian Horoscopes, 1998).
- ~ 150
Alexandria. Ptolemy writes the trade's bible.
The Tetrabiblos sets the rules still used today: twelve signs, planets, houses, aspects. Ptolemy was also the reference astronomer for 1,400 years. At the time, astronomy and astrology meant the same science.
- 9th century
Baghdad. Abu Ma'shar saves and passes on.
At the House of Wisdom, the Persian scholar compiled the Greeks, Persians and Indians. His Great Introduction, translated into Latin in the 12th century, brought astrology back to Europe. Without the Arab-Muslim world, a large part of Greek knowledge would have been lost.
- 1601
Prague. Kepler, the divorce.
The man who discovered the laws of planetary orbits earned his living with horoscopes. He called astrology “the foolish daughter” whom her wise mother, astronomy, could not do without in order to eat. From then on, the two roads parted for good.
- 1861
Paris. Éliphas Lévi writes this guide's sentence.
In La Clef des grands mystères (The Key of the Mysteries), the French occultist translated Paracelsus's Prognostication: the stars “push us by their influence, but if the master wills it, he alone can divert and change everything”. Box below.
- 24 August 1930
London. The newspaper horoscope is born.
The Sunday Express asked the astrologer R. H. Naylor to comment on the birth of Princess Margaret. Instant success, weekly column. The sun-sign column, twelve paragraphs for the whole of humanity, is a newspaper invention, not a tradition.
- 1952
Zurich. Jung publishes Synchronicity.
With the Nobel physics laureate Wolfgang Pauli, he tried to give a framework to meaningful coincidences. In it he describes his own astrological experiment on 483 married couples. Chapter 4.
- 1985
Berkeley. The Nature test.
Shawn Carlson gave 28 recognised astrologers the test they had validated themselves. Result at chance level. Chapter 3.
- 2017
New York. Co-Star, and the comeback.
An app calculates your full chart in a second and sends you notifications. In France, in 2022, 64% of people read their horoscope; among 18 to 24-year-olds, 55% think their sign explains character and one in two asks the sign of someone they like (Ifop).
“We do not attribute a fatal power to the stars; they push us by their influence, but if the master wills it, he alone can divert and change everything.”
Paracelsus, translated by Éliphas Lévi, La Clef des grands mystères, Paris, 1861. And a few lines further on: “The brute undergoes the fatalities of this light; man can direct it.” Lévi actually opens his chapter with the most sceptical sentence of antiquity, which he attributes to Socrates: “What is above us does not exist for us.”
What one of the greatest occultists of the 19th century writes in black and white is that even for those who believe in it, the sky proposes, man disposes. I don't subscribe to his “astral light”. But this whole guide fits in that nuance, and I found it there, not with a sceptic.
Your sign is one box out of twelve. Your chart is a whole sentence.
Magazine astrology reads a single word of your sky: the position of the Sun. A birth chart (or natal chart) reads about thirty: the complete map of the sky at the minute and place of your birth. Here are the three you need to know, then the rest of the grammar.
Your “official” sign. The sign the Sun was crossing at your birth. In astrology, it describes what you strive towards, your way of wanting to exist. It's the only word horoscopes read. It changes every 30 days: about 650 million people share it with you.
What you feel when nobody is looking. The Moon changes sign every two and a half days. Astrologers read emotional needs in it, the way you reassure yourself. Two Aries with different Moons don't resemble each other at all. It's often there that people “recognise themselves”.
The front door. The sign rising on the eastern horizon at the minute of your birth. It changes every two hours, hence astrologers' obsession with the exact time. It describes the first impression you give. Without a birth time, no ascendant, no houses.
- Mercurythought, speech, messages
- Venusthe way you love and charm
- Marsdesire, anger, action
- Jupiterexpansion, luck, excess
- Saturnlimits, time, maturity
- The slow onesUranus, Neptune, Pluto: generational, shared by your whole age group
Twelve sectors of the sky, calculated from the ascendant: money, family, work, the couple (7th house), intimacy (8th house)… A planet takes its meaning from the house it falls in.
The angles between planets. Conjunction (0°) and trine (120°) are read as flowing; square (90°) and opposition (180°) as tensions. That's where the “compatibility” between two charts, synastry, is played out (chapter 5).
Why it's so often spot on. Cycles, and what they hide.
A chart is a photo. Transits are the film: the planets keep turning and “activate” your map. It's the most troubling part of astrology, because the planets have rhythms, and so do our lives.
- 29.5years
The Saturn return
Saturn takes 29 and a half years to come back to where it was at your birth. Astrologers see in it the end of youth: you leave, you take responsibility, you build. And indeed, between 27 and 30, many people change city, job, partner.
What's hidden behind it: the end of studies, the first real income, the social pressure of “at your age”. The biological and social calendar does the work. Saturn arrives at the right moment, like a guest who knocks when the party has already started.
- 3 to 4times a year
Mercury retrograde
For three weeks, three or four times a year, Mercury seems to move backwards in the sky, through a simple effect of perspective between two orbits. Social media blames it for everything: misread messages, bugs, exes who reappear.
What's hidden behind it: Mercury is “retrograde” about 19% of the time. One problem in five falls within it by arithmetic. And as soon as you know it's the period, you notice every misunderstanding. You never count those of the other weeks.
- 12years
The Jupiter cycle, and Barbault's index
Jupiter comes back every twelve years, read as a year of opening. The French astrologer André Barbault went further: a “cyclical index” of the slow planets to date the world's crises. In a 2011 text, he announced a global health crisis for 2020-2021.
What to make of it: it's troubling, and it's a single case remembered among dozens of forecasts that weren't. We remember the arrow that hit. Nobody counts the ones that fell in the grass.
Before saying “it's the transit”, ask yourself: how often does this happen anyway? A break-up, a move, an argument: life supplies enough of them for any cycle to catch a few. A cycle that “hits” once proves nothing. A cycle that hit more often than chance, across thousands of lives, measured in advance, would prove everything. That's exactly the test the next chapter tells.
I haven't checked whether my Saturn return fell in the year I left everything for Marrakech. I'd rather not know. I already know what my brain would do with that information.
It's been tested. Often, seriously, and with astrologers themselves.
Astrology makes verifiable claims: the birth sky says something about character, and two skies say something about a couple. Here's what happens when you check.
The test astrologers wrote themselves
Shawn Carlson, a physicist at Berkeley, designed with renowned astrologers a protocol they considered fair. 28 practitioners received the charts of 116 people and three personality profiles (the CPI), including the true one. They predicted at least 50% success. Result: 40 out of 116, or one in three. Chance. Even on the charts they said they were very confident about.
2003 · Dean and KellyThe time twins
If the birth sky matters, two strangers born in the same place a few minutes apart should resemble each other. A British cohort follows more than 2,000 people born in London in March 1958, across more than 100 variables: IQ, anxiety, sociability, occupation, marital status. No similarity beyond chance.
2007 · Voas, University of ManchesterTen million marriages
David Voas crossed the sun signs of 10 million married couples from the census of England and Wales. If some signs attracted each other, it would show in such a number. Nothing. None of the 144 combinations is more frequent. The only anomaly, an excess of couples born on the same day, is explained by data-entry errors.
2020 · Lu et al., 173,709 peopleSign and character, large-number version
In China, a team compared the signs of 173,709 adults with their personality traits (the Big Five), then the performance of 32,878 employees. No link. As early as 1999, van Rooij had shown the flaw: people who know their sign describe themselves a little more like it. Those who don't know it, don't.
If the sky predicts nothing, why do I recognise myself every time?
Because your brain is a meaning-finding machine, and astrology is the best fuel ever invented for that machine. Nothing shameful: the same mechanisms run in sceptics.
- 1
The Barnum effect
In 1948, Bertram Forer gave 39 students a “personalised” portrait. They rated it 4.26 out of 5. It was the same for everyone, cut out of a horoscope: “You have a need for other people to like you, yet you tend to be critical of yourself.” A sentence true of everyone is felt as true of oneself.
- 2
Confirmation bias
You remember the three times the Scorpio really was jealous. You forget the ten times they weren't, and the Taurus who was. Your brain doesn't keep accounts, it keeps a photo album, and only files the pictures that confirm the legend.
- 3
The frequency illusion
You learn a word, you hear it everywhere the following week. You decide 11:11 means something, you see it every day. The world hasn't changed. Your filter has. Psychologists speak of apophenia: seeing patterns in noise.
- 4
The need for control
In 1998, Lillqvist and Lindeman showed that people turn to astrology above all in times of crisis: break-up, bereavement, unemployment. When life becomes unreadable, a system that makes it readable brings relief. Even false, it makes chaos bearable. Especially false, sometimes.
- 5
Projection
A chart is vague enough for you to pour into it what you already know about yourself. What you “discover” reading your Moon is what you didn't dare put into words. Astrology guessed nothing: it gave you permission to say it. That's already a lot.
- 6
Shared language
“He's very Moon in Cancer” takes five seconds to say and opens a conversation about emotions two friends would never otherwise have had. Astrology is a social language before it is a theory. That's why it survives every refutation.
When you recognise yourself in your chart, it isn't the sky reading you. It's you reading yourself, through it. That takes nothing away from the value of what you find. It only changes the sender's address. And it changes everything when it comes to a sign about someone else: they didn't send you anything.
The mirror hours that made me wait.
It started a few weeks after the end. I look at my phone: 11:11. I smile. The next day, 22:22 leaving a dinner. Then a song we used to listen to together, in a taxi, at the exact moment I was thinking of her. A number plate with her number. In three months, I had a collection.
And every piece of the collection said the same thing: the universe is talking to me, it isn't over, she's thinking of me, she'll come back. I didn't tell anyone. But I fell asleep with it. And I decided things with it: not answering a certain person, leaving a door open, waiting a little longer.
One evening, after seeing 11:11 so often, I did a very simple calculation, the kind you avoid when you're hoping. 11:11 comes round twice a day. I look at my phone about 80 times a day. I had been landing on a mirror hour two or three times a week for years. I'd just never had a reason to notice them.
Mirror hours have no astrological tradition: they come from the “angel” numerology popularised on the internet in the 2000s. What psychology knows very well, on the other hand, is the mechanism: the frequency illusion (your attention filters what matters to you), rumination after a break-up (Bernstein and McNally showed in 2017 that it keeps the pain going, and that a session of physical exercise breaks it), and intermittent reinforcement: a reward that comes from time to time, with no rule, makes a behaviour almost impossible to stop. A mirror hour is a slot machine that pays out in hope.
The sign talks about her. It comes from outside, it brings me information about what she feels, about what will happen.
“The universe is telling me she's coming back.”
The sign talks about me. It measures exactly one thing: how much I still think about her. It's a thermometer, not a compass.
“I haven't moved on.”
Every sign extended the wait by a week. And waiting is the only place where nothing can be repaired, not with her, not with someone else, not with myself.
Six months. At the very least.
The rule I've applied since: a synchronicity talks about you, never about the other person. When I see a sign, I no longer ask myself “what does it announce?” but “what does it say about where I am?”. The answer is less romantic. It's usable.
The ex-comeback industry.
All it took was one video. Just one, on a weak evening, titled “Pick a card: what he or she feels for you right now”. The next day, my feed was nothing but that. “Your ex will come back before the end of the month.” “Twin flame: the signs he's thinking of you.” “Why the Scorpio always comes back.” Hundreds of thousands of views each.
I watched, out of curiosity at first, then less out of curiosity. And I understood the model. These videos predict nothing: they sell the only thing a person who is waiting wants to buy, a reason to wait a little longer. Three cards, three answers, all compatible with a return. The fourth option, “he has moved on”, never exists. It isn't astrology, it's marketing that has stolen its vocabulary.
The French online tarot and clairvoyance market was worth about 515 million euros in 2024. Studying the Instagram accounts of tarot readers, the researcher Edith Eglem noted the typical offer: “two questions for €10”. Ten euros to hear that it isn't over. And the following week, ten more.
This content exploits the intermittent reinforcement described by Skinner, and what Lillqvist and Lindeman measured: in times of crisis, we look for readability, and we pay to get it. In France, 2% of people consult a clairvoyant, but 29% believe in card reading (Ifop, 2022). The audience is there. The algorithm knows how to find it.
I don't blame those who watch. I watched. I blame this content for wearing the clothes of astrology, a four-thousand-year-old tradition, to sell waiting by the gram. A real astrologer will never tell you your ex is coming back. They'll talk to you about you. If someone talks to you about the other person, what they feel, what they'll do, close the video. It isn't the sky talking. It's the view counter.
- 1
“He's thinking of you right now.”
Unverifiable, and true of everyone at one time or another.
- 2
“He'll come back, but not straight away.”
The promise with a moving date: it can never be false.
- 3
“He's your twin flame.”
The concept makes a break-up impossible to accept by definition.
- 4
“The universe is testing you.”
Pain becomes an ordeal to pass. Leaving becomes a failure.
- 5
“To find out more, in private.”
The moment hope becomes an invoice.
Jung believed in it, tested it, and concluded otherwise.
Carl Gustav Jung, founder of analytical psychology, spent forty years with astrology. Not as a horoscope reader: as a researcher. His path is the best answer I have found to the question of this guide.
- 1911
The letter to Freud
On 12 June 1911, Jung wrote to Freud that he was spending his nights on astrology, “indispensable for understanding mythology”. Freud was worried. Jung carried on: he saw in the planets archetypes, images humanity had projected onto the sky to talk to itself about itself.
- 1950
The marriage experiment
He wanted proof. He gathered the charts of 483 married couples (966 people) and checked whether the aspects tradition associates with marriage (Sun-Moon, Moon-Moon, Moon-ascendant) were more frequent than in 32,220 false pairs drawn at random. The first batch, 180 couples, gave a spectacular result. Jung was elated.
- 1952
Back down to earth
The following batches fell back to the average. Worse: each batch “favoured” a different aspect, and always the one the team was hoping for. Jung concluded, with rare honesty, that the result reflected the researchers' state of mind, not the planets. He published anyway, in Synchronicity, written with the physicist Wolfgang Pauli, a Nobel laureate.
- 1954
The letter to Barbault
To the French astrologer André Barbault, he wrote on 26 May 1954 that astrology “has something to offer psychology” but that he saw no causality in it. The sky does nothing. Sometimes the sky and we say the same thing at the same moment. That's a synchronicity.
A patient tells Jung of a dream in which she is given a golden scarab. At the same instant, an insect taps on the window: a rose chafer, the closest thing to a scarab in those latitudes. Jung catches it and hands it to her. The patient, until then locked in her reason, finally starts to move. The coincidence predicted nothing. It unblocked something.
Synchronicity: the coincidence, in time, of two facts with no cause-and-effect link, but which have the same meaning for the person living them. The key words are the last ones: for the person living them.
A synchronicity, for Jung, is never a message from outside about someone else. It's a moment when the outside rhymes with your inside, and which shows you where you are. My 11:11 said nothing about her. It said I was still there, waiting for her. Jung would have found that very interesting. He wouldn't have taken out the cards. He would have asked me: “And what are you going to do with it?”
Compatibility: a bad verdict, an excellent topic of conversation.
Ten million marriages showed no affinity between signs. And yet one young person in two asks the sign of someone they like. Both facts are true. Here's how to reconcile them.
| Element | Fire | Earth | Air | Water |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fire | same flame | friction | fans it | steam |
| Earth | friction | solid | storm | fertile |
| Air | fans it | storm | light | mist |
| Water | steam | fertile | mist | deep |
Fire: Aries, Leo, Sagittarius · Earth: Taurus, Virgo, Capricorn · Air: Gemini, Libra, Aquarius · Water: Cancer, Scorpio, Pisces. Real astrologers compare whole charts (synastry): Venus, Mars, the Moon, cross aspects. Never the sun sign alone.
sign combinations more frequent than chance among 10 million married couples. If fire and water ran from each other, we would see it.
Voas, University of Manchester, 2007Tradition promises intensity and predicts wear and tear. What it really points to: what you do when you both want the same thing at the same time.
To ask each other: who slows down, in our couple?
The pair reputed to be easy. Its risk is that one carries all the emotions and the other all the logistics, without anyone having chosen it.
To ask each other: who cries, who pays the bills?
Supposedly the worst. Above all it's a couple where one expresses by acting and the other by feeling. That isn't fixed with a sign. It's fixed with a translation.
To ask each other: how do you show you care about me?
No data condemns them. But if you both believe in it, you'll interpret every argument as fate. Astrology doesn't predict the break-up. Believing in it can help bring it about.
To ask each other: do we believe in it, or do we use it?
Confession: I checked our compatibility. After the end, not before. It was excellent. Two charts that agree have never stopped two people from talking past each other. Real synastry is the test that follows: it's done as two, and with words.
The only compatibility test that has evidence.
Each of you answers separately, in secret: A (it's me), B (more the other), C (we both handle it badly). Then you compare. The score doesn't count. The disagreements do: that's where the conversation begins.
Who sends the first message after an argument?
Who needs to talk straight away, who needs to wait?
Who shows attachment through gestures rather than words?
Who suggests the plans, who follows them?
Who feels neglected when the other sees their friends?
Who brings up money first, and who avoids it?
Who says “I love you” most often, and who says it best?
Who checks the other's phone in their head, even without doing it?
Who brings the family into the relationship, and how?
Who believes things will sort themselves out?
Why this test and not another. Couples researchers (Gottman; Finkel et al., 2012) have never found a “compatible” profile. They found ways of handling differences: everything plays out in the repair after a disagreement, not in the absence of disagreement. Do it with her, with him. Not on her, not on him.
The sky will never tell you whether you're loved. A circle that comes back will.
What I was looking for in the mirror hours was an answer to a simple question: do I matter to someone? Astrology can't answer. It can only make the question last. Lafter is neither therapy nor a substitute religion. It's a place where the question gets an answer every week, from real people.
Monday, Wednesday, Friday at 7am, and the Saturday run club. Bernstein and McNally (2017) measured it: thirty minutes of effort reduce rumination after emotional stress. You don't look at your phone running through the Palmeraie. You don't see 11:11. You see people who were waiting for you at 7am, and who will wait for you on Wednesday.
2 · Lafter Connect: meaning is built, not guessedOn Sunday, fifteen people, and someone who passes on what they know how to do. What astrology sells you as a revelation about yourself, a workshop gives you in a verifiable version: you discover what you like, what you know, what you want, by doing it in front of others. No chart, no cards. Evidence.
3 · Tuesday: a date that depends on no signThe Lafter Coffee comes back every Tuesday at 8pm, Mercury retrograde or not. For someone who has spent months waiting for a sign, regularity is the real treatment: you no longer need the universe to wink at you to know you have a place somewhere. You have it, and it has a time.
4 · The same faces: reading togetherAlone with your chart, you project. At the table with your circle, someone tells you “you, Moon in Cancer? what you mostly need is for people to answer you within the hour”. The language of signs becomes what it has always done best: a way of talking about yourself, corrected live by people who really know you.
Come on a Tuesday instead of looking at a card. Count the people who say your first name. It's the only prediction that can be checked that same evening.
You'll be right about the science, and you'll be the only one at the table not laughing when we compare ascendants. Come anyway. We need you for chapter 3.
Free to discover. No commitment. Nobody will ask your sign before your first name.
Save my seatThe 7 rules for reading the sky without getting lost in it.
I haven't stopped looking up. I've changed the way I read. These seven rules are the ones I wish I'd had in the autumn of 2024, when every mirror hour cost me a week.
- 1
A sign talks about you, never about the other person
If the interpretation is about what someone else feels or will do, it's no longer a reading. It's a hope in disguise. Turn the question back to yourself.
- 2
Read your chart, not your sign
The Sun alone is the press. Sun, Moon, ascendant and the rest is a language. If you're going to spend time on it, spend it on the version that really resembles you.
- 3
Ask for the base rate before the transit
“It's Mercury”? How often does this problem happen anyway? If the answer is “often”, the planet has nothing to do with it.
- 4
Never a decision on a reading alone
The sky can open a question. It doesn't close it. Before acting, a real witness, a night's sleep, and a reason you could defend without astrology.
- 5
Close any video that talks about your ex
“Pick a card”, “he's thinking of you”, “twin flame”: you're not the audience, you're the product. The view counter has no ascendant.
- 6
Use it to talk, not to classify
“You're very Moon in Cancer” is an excellent first sentence and a very bad conclusion. Ask the next question. That's the one that counts.
- 7
An earthly date for every heavenly reading
Every time you consult the sky, schedule something real: a coffee, a run at 7am, a Tuesday. The sky proposes. Your calendar disposes.
Every sign you see, write it below with the date and what you hoped for. In a month, reread. You'll see what the collection really tells.
For every trait you recognise yourself in, look for a time you did the opposite. If you find it easily, the trait wasn't yours. It belonged to everyone.
When someone talks to you about their sign, they're talking to you about themselves. Don't correct the astronomy. Listen to the person. You'll have the science and the friend.
At the end of the month, look at the middle column: if it always says the same first name, the sky has taught you nothing about that person. It has taught you something about yourself.
Get the printable notebookThe stars incline. They don't decide.
I spent two years asking the sky whether someone was going to come back. It never answered me, because that isn't its job. Its job, for four thousand years, has been to give us a language to talk about ourselves. I'm keeping it. But I've given back to the sky what didn't belong to it: my decisions, my expectations, and my Tuesdays. The Lafter Coffee, Tuesday 8pm, is the simplest place to start. Free to discover, no commitment.
Save my seatThe PDF to keep, annotate and lend.
The magazine edition, 20 pages, in French for now.
The test for two and the notebook of signs are filled in with a pencil.
Guide No. 04 is ready. Print it, annotate it, lend it.
Download the PDF (3.7 MB)Frequently asked questions
Does astrology work?
To predict character or the future, no: controlled tests (Carlson 1985, Dean and Kelly 2003, Voas 2007, Lu 2020) come out at chance level. To talk about yourself, put words to things and open conversations, yes, and that is measurable too. The misunderstanding comes from what we ask of it.
What is the difference between a star sign and a birth chart?
The (sun) sign is the position of the Sun at your birth, one box out of twelve. The birth chart is the complete map of the sky at your minute and place of birth: Moon, ascendant, planets, houses, aspects. Serious astrologers never read the sign alone.
Did my sign change with Ophiuchus?
No. Western astrology uses seasonal signs, not constellations. The constellations have shifted by about 24° since antiquity (the precession of the equinoxes), and Ophiuchus has always been there. What NASA published in 2016 was an educational astronomy page, not a reform of the zodiac.
Is Mercury retrograde real?
The optical phenomenon, yes: three to four times a year, Mercury seems to move backwards through an effect of perspective. The effect on your messages, no. But as it is “retrograde” for nearly a fifth of the year, one misunderstanding in five falls within it by simple arithmetic.
Are mirror hours (11:11, 22:22) astrology?
No. They come from the “angel” numerology of the 2000s. They rest on the frequency illusion: 11:11 comes round twice a day, and you only notice it when you have a reason to. A mirror hour measures your attention, not a message.
What does Islam say about astrology?
The Muslim tradition clearly distinguishes astronomy, which is encouraged (the calendar, the direction of prayer, the golden age of Baghdad), from divination by the stars, which is forbidden: claiming to know the future or the unseen is reserved for God. Many Moroccans read their horoscope knowing this. This guide doesn't settle religious questions; it notes that on one point, science and tradition say the same thing: the sky doesn't predict your life.
Can you trust star sign compatibility in love?
Among 10 million married couples, no combination of signs is more frequent than chance. What couples research finds is that lasting depends on how you repair after a disagreement, not on an initial affinity. This guide's test for two measures that.
Did Jung believe in astrology?
He took it very seriously for forty years, ran his own experiment on 483 couples, and concluded there was no causality. He saw in it a reservoir of archetypes and a field for his notion of synchronicity: coincidences that are meaningful to the person living them, without the sky doing anything.
Can you love astrology and be sceptical?
It is even the most comfortable position. You keep the language, the curiosity, the game at the table, and you leave the predictions. The rule: a sign talks about you, never about the other person, and never a decision on a reading alone.
Is Lafter an anti-astrology circle?
Not at all: half the table knows its ascendant. Lafter is a private friendship circle in Marrakech, by co-optation, where you see the same faces every week. It replaces the one thing astrology does badly: waiting for a sign to know whether you matter to someone.
What this text is based on
The 11 sources, numbered
- Francesca Rochberg, Babylonian Horoscopes, American Philosophical Society, 1998. Claudius Ptolemy, Tetrabiblos, 2nd century; Abu Ma'shar, Kitab al-Mudkhal al-Kabir, 9th century.
- Éliphas Lévi, “La Clef des grands mystères”, Germer Baillière, Paris, 1861 (copy digitised by the Bibliothèque nationale de France).
- Shawn Carlson, “A double-blind test of astrology”, Nature, vol. 318, 1985.
- Geoffrey Dean and Ivan Kelly, “Is astrology relevant to consciousness and psi?”, Journal of Consciousness Studies, 2003 (the time twins).
- David Voas, “Ten million marriages: an astrological detective story”, Skeptical Inquirer, 2008; University of Manchester, 2007.
- Bertram Forer, “The fallacy of personal validation”, Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1948. Jan van Rooij, “Self-concept in terms of astrological sun-sign traits”, Personality and Individual Differences, 1999. Lu et al., “Zodiac signs and personality”, 2020. Andersson et al., 2021.
- Outi Lillqvist and Marjaana Lindeman, “Belief in astrology as a strategy for self-verification and coping with negative life-events”, European Psychologist, 1998.
- C. G. Jung, Synchronicity, 1952 (with W. Pauli, Naturerklärung und Psyche); The Freud/Jung Letters, letter of 12 June 1911; letter from Jung to André Barbault, 26 May 1954.
- Emily Bernstein and Richard McNally, “Acute aerobic exercise helps overcome emotion regulation deficits”, Cognition and Emotion, 2017.
- Ifop for Femme Actuelle, “Les Français et l'ésotérisme”, April 2022, 1,012 people. Edith Eglem, study of tarot readers on Instagram. French clairvoyance market 2024: press estimates, to be taken as an order of magnitude.
- NASA Space Place, “Constellations and the calendar”, 2016. John Gottman, The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work, 1999; Finkel et al., Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 2012.
The scenes in the notebook were lived and are told from my point of view alone; the person mentioned is neither named nor identifiable, and she has her version, as true as mine. Thirty studies read, Lévi's PDF annotated, six weeks watching what the algorithm serves someone who types “ex coming back”. Where a source is fragile (the clairvoyance market, Barbault's forecast), I say so in the text. This guide is neither a diagnosis nor a consultation, and takes no position on anyone's religious convictions.
After the sky, the night. Why you dream of your ex months later, what Freud and Jung said about it, what sleep laboratories have measured since, and why dream dictionaries are the wrong dictionary. With my own dreams from 2024, and a method for writing them down without over-interpreting them.
A mistake, a source to add? Write to contact@lafter.ma: every correction is dated.
Places mentioned
- Marrakech
- Koutoubia
To cite this text
Prost, Jérémy (Jay). “Astrology: should you believe in it?”. The Lafter guides, No. 04, Lafter, Marrakech, updated 22 November 2026. lafter.ma/en/guides/astrology-should-you-believe-in-it

I founded Lafter in Marrakech, a circle where you see the same faces every week. I write these texts like a report: a question that concerns me, the studies that answer it, and my own story, when it helps understanding. Every figure is sourced.
My background and the method →















